jump to navigation

401(k) confusion April 26, 2006

Posted by irishmadness in 401(k), Saving.
trackback

I’ve been getting a lot of questions from co-workers about 401(k)s lately, and I’m kind of surprised at how little people understand about them. I guess my parents did me more of a favor than they thought when they got me that Zillions subscription as a kid. :)

Jennie’s rules for 401(k) contributions

1. Don’t put your own money into company stock. If the company match is in company stock, regularly transfer it to other funds. You already have too much of your future tied up in your company’s financial success, especially if your have stock options or a pension. Don’t put your 401(k) in their hands too.

2. No matter how broke you are, always invest at least enough to get the company match. As Suze Orman points out in “Young, Fabulous and Broke,” where else can you get 50 percent or more return on your money? It’s basically free money.

3. Start a 401(k) as soon as you can. The earlier you start, the more you have of your greatest assest - time. One guy I know who’s several years older than me has about 10 times what I do in his account. But if we both stopped investing today, I’ll be way better off when I retire in 35 years than when he retires in 20 because the balance keeps compounding.

4. Don’t cash out your 401(k) when you leave a job. Count this as a lesson I learned the hard way. I started one when I was 21 and working my first job after college. I built up a decent amount, maybe $3,500 in three years. When I left, instead of being smart and rolling it over, I cashed it out to pay down my credit card. But I wasn’t committed to killing my debt yet, so the balance went back up, I had to pay all the lovely tax penalties and I lost out on all the money I would have earned over the next 40 years.

5. Be wary of taking out a loan from your 401(k). Maybe things will be fine and you’ll be able to pay it back. But what if you lose your job? What if you leave your job? What if you decide you hate your job but can’t leave because you can’t afford to pay back the loan? Taking a loan really restricts your options and shouldn’t be used if you have another alternative.

6. Know what your portfolio should look like for your stage in life. If you invest too conservatively early on, you won’t make enough money to retire on. If you keep an aggressive portfolio too long, you risk a stock market crash or major downturn just as you’re getting ready to join the ranks of the retired. Start out aggressive, and tweak your portfolio over time to be more conservative.

7. Resist the urge to fiddle. This is a long-term investment. Adjusting your contribution rate and portfolio once a year is good. Changing it every other week is not. Also, don’t panic over blips in the stock market, epecially if you’re a 20-something like me. The point of this is long-term investing, not making a quick profit. There are going to be weeks or months that things aren’t doing so well. Keep investing - you’ll pick up more shares because they’re cheaper and be in better shape when the stock market picks up again.

8. That said, when you do move money out of a fund, do it over time. If you have a third of your 401(k) in company stock and you just realized that’s not a smart move, don’t go in tomorrow and move it all out. Figure out how long a time frame you’re comfortable with and divide the balance by that amount, then transfer that amount each week. (My company match amount is fairly small, so I’ve been moving $100 a week, and will be done in June.) This evens out the cost of the stock so you’re less likely to have one of those wonderful moments where you sell off big and the stock shoots up the following week.

Any other suggestions for smart 401(k) investing?

Comments»

1. Aleta - April 26, 2006

“Know what your portfolio should look like for your stage in life.”

I would expand this to — know the risk level you are comfortable with.

I am 42 and at least 25 years from Social Security Retirement (67, for me). I prefer to have a very aggressive portfolio. In my government 401(k), my assets are ~ 16% fixed income (government securities and fixed income index) and 84% stocks (common, small cap, and international). In the one from my previous job, which I haven’t rolled over because it is TIAA-CREF and not institution-specific, I have ~23% in more-fixed income (annuity and bond) and 77% in stocks (stock, global, growth, and equity).

I would actually prefer, at this point, to be almost 1/3 international stocks to balance the rest, but I haven’t sat down to think things through. That said, my mix is much more aggressive than people I know who are my age. But I didn’t start until post-grad school, at age 33. I have a lot of catching up to do.

2. Aleta - April 26, 2006

CNN.com referenced this site: http://www.alliancebernstein.com/retcalculator/Investor.aspx

According to what I have saved and what I contribute, if I want to retire at age 65 and expect to have a 20 year retirement and not run out of money, I could withdraw $48,000 in today’s dollars per year. I increase the likelihood of running out of money if I withdraw $59,000. If I increase my contributions by 1%, I could withdraw $51,000 per year.

This is a good illustration of how time, and small increases in contributions, can have a huge impact. If I had continued my retirement plan in MA — that is, with the salary I was earning there and the 10% contribution I was making, starting at age 33 — I would be able to withdraw $60,000 per year in today’s dollars. Making less money, but starting earlier and contributing a bigger percentage, resulted in being able to withdraw $12,000 per year for 20 years more — or almost a quarter of a million dollars!

3. Chitowngirl - April 26, 2006

Great post. I’m 28 and I don’t have nearly enough in stocks at this point and need to reallocate.

4. Maryland Hyundai Car Dealer - January 15, 2007

What do you think of the new Hyundai Sonata?